Your Hometown 9

Links

Why the Wildcard Works

August 26th, 2008

Baseball purists believe the Wildcard rule is untraditional. After all, a pennant is a pennant is a pennant. But I’m here to say, it works. As a Ranger fan, my hopes for post season glory would have been over long ago with the high flying Angels ruling the AL West roost. But instead, there has been hope……possibly dashed recently by losing 10 of 14, but still it is there…..just a mere 10.5 games away. Hopeless? Yeah, probably. Worth watching still? Yeah, definitely.

The Argument Against:

1. Winning the division doesn’t mean anything anymore - I think it still does, since there’s only ONE wildcard team against THREE division winners. 75% of the teams making the MLB playoffs have to win their Division. Compare that to 67% for the NFL, and 38% in the NBA.

2. Wildcard teams are winning World Series - True in the case of Boston, St Louis and Florida have turned the trick recently. But is this bad?

3. Too many teams in the hunt at the Trade Deadline stymies the chance at “the great trade” - While more teams are in it, it certainly didn’t stop big names from changing hands in 2008. Manny Ramirez, Griffey, Bay, Sabathia, among others. Besides, why is it such a good thing to see half the league basically GIVE UP in July and dump their roster?

The Argument For :

1. More teams with more hope in September - This year is a little exception, since both Wild Card leaders have excellent records, but there are still 8 teams chasing with decent chances right now.

2. Wildcard teams are winning World Series - Maybe proof that ramping your game up to clinch a late playoff spot BETTER prepares you for the post season than coasting in with a 15 game division lead.

3. More drama to combat the NFL - Ok, so I love the NFL…..but game 2 of the NFL season shouldn’t be as pivotal as a September showdown series in a pennant chase. Wildcard races “make it matter”.

So, let’s keep the Wildcard around for a bit……The 2007 Mets proved to us that any overpaid band of prima donnas can choke and keep YOUR team’s hopes alive.

Related Posts

  • No Related Post

 

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Official Baseball Rules

Sponsors

Please contact us about sponsership via the contact us page.

Advertise with Us

Please contact us about advertising via the contact us page.